“What’s Up on Polkadot?” – Your One-Stop Hub for Polkadot Events, Airdrops and Learning Opportunities by web3rdy

TimedOut
Content
AI Summary
Reply
Up
Share
Request
1,000DOT
Tally
0%Aye
100.0%Threshold
100%Nay
Aye
11.5KDOT
Nay
46.49MDOT
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

    Threshold

  • 0.0%
Support
0.00%
4,517DOT
Issuance
1.59BDOT
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Actions
Check how referenda works here.
Call
Metadata
Timeline2
Votes Bubble
Curves
Statistics
Comments

hello,

Can you mention the team in carge of this product? thanks

Reply
Up

.

Edited

Reply
Up

PolkaWorld votes NAY

1.	These features will be integrated into the Polkadot App in the future!
2.	Without significant incentives and marketing power, it will be very difficult to change user habits across platforms.

See more feedback here.

Reply
Up

no Decision Deposit?

Reply
Up

JAM DAO voted NAY on this proposal

While the proposal may have had good intentions, the DAO collectively determined that it did not meet the quality standards required for treasury funding at this time. The proposal drew widespread concern among members across multiple dimensions:

Ecosystem & Treasury Misalignment

Many members felt the initiative was not a strong use of treasury resources given current priorities. There was broad consensus that this type of project, lacking both open-source commitment and ecosystem alignment, does not warrant public funding.

Product Quality Concerns

  1. DAO members flagged the MVP as unconvincing and lacking in critical areas such as:
  2. Clear UX/UI flow or diagrams
  3. Functional clarity and community maintainability
  4. Without these, members found it difficult to see how the product would serve the broader ecosystem or deliver long-term value.

Sustainability & Maintenance Risks

The fact that the project was not open-source was a significant red flag. Members raised the concern that without open-sourcing, the initiative risks:

  • Becoming unmaintainable if the proposer disengages
  • Becoming a recurring cost to the treasury without a revenue or sustainability model
  • Not allowing for broader community contribution or forkability

DAO members emphasized that future proposals should include clearer deliverables, sustainability plans, open-source commitment, and a demonstrated connection to ecosystem needs.

Reply
Up