Referendum #1390

Talisman - Mobile Wallet Proposal

Big Spender
1mo ago
19 Comments
Executed
Content
AI Summary
Reply
Up 1
Share
Request
598.1KUSDT
Status
Decision28d
Confirmation7d
Attempts
1
Tally
78%Aye
50.0%Threshold
22%Nay
Aye
24.42MDOT
Nay
6.87MDOT
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

Threshold

Support0.38%
5.87MDOT
Issuance
1.53BDOT
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Calls
Call
Metadata
Timeline6
Votes Bubble
Statistics
Comments

I appreciate the progress made with the desktop app and the ambition to expand to mobile. However, the proposal lacks details about Talisman’s financial health, such as income statements or balance sheets —though perhaps I missed it. Providing this information would help assess the project's sustainability and determine how many more funding rounds might be needed. Supporting a company on the road to profitability is far more compelling than backing one reliant on ongoing treasury funding to avoid financial challenges. Transparency here would build confidence and strengthen community support for this initiative.

Reply
Up

Lucky Friday have voted AYE. Please consider this a temporary notification after our vote has gone on chain. If you would like additional feedback on our rationale for this vote, please join our OpenGov Public Forum on Telegram here: https://t.me/+559tyPSfmGg0NzUx

Lucky Friday provides feedback once per week (Fridays) if specifically requested in our OpenGov Public Forum, and we respectfully ask that all proponents of referenda interact with us here for the sake of transparency. Please tag our Head of Protocol Partnerships “Phunky” with your referendum number so that he can gather the relevant commentary from our internal deliberations.

Reply
Up

Dear @Warp Lizard | Talisman,

Thank you for your proposal. Our vote on this proposal is AYE.

The Big Spender track requires 60% quorum according to our voting policy. This proposal has received nine aye and zero nay votes from ten members. Below is a summary of our members' comments:

The referendum received unanimous support, with members highlighting Talisman’s importance as one of the leading wallets in the Polkadot ecosystem. Supporters praised the initiative for introducing competition, enhancing the mobile wallet space, and building on Talisman’s success with its browser extension. While some raised questions about resource allocation and overlap with the browser extension team, the proposal was widely viewed as a positive step for the ecosystem. Members expressed optimism about the product's potential and its role in fostering user-friendly adoption.

The full discussion can be found in our internal voting.

Kind regards,
Permanence DAO

Reply
Up

I have a question :
When will the Talisman wallet and any other wallet on Polkadot be self-sustainable?

Reply
Up