Bounty: The Genesis Incentive Pool

Big Spender
16 Comments
Rejected
  • Content
  • AI Summary
Reply
Up
Share
Status
Decision28d
Confirmation2d
Attempts
0
Tally
18.4%Aye
50.0%Threshold
81.6%Nay
Aye
8.17MDOT
Nay
36.16MDOT
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

Threshold

Support(0.34%)
4MDOT
Issuance
1.19BDOT
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Calls
  • Call
  • Metadata
  • Timeline4
  • Votes Bubble
  • Statistics
    New
Comments

Strong NO, because:

  • It gives Talisman advantages that other ecosystem participants have no. And other teams will come for the similar advantages and will ask for another 1-2-3M DOT, its not effective spending at all.
  • 1M DOTs - guys, come on! Are you going to invite 1 billion new users to Polkadot? Or one user will cost 1-2K$?
  • Operational costs 75k$ per month , and you are going to SELL all of this on the market on monthly basis? I think its better to wait for good times to invest 1M DOTs at better price.
  • You are a commercial company, why 100% of your costs need to be covered by Polkadot treasury. Add more paid features for your users , use validators and staking to earn for the operational costs.
  • "0.25 DOTs commission for each additional staked DOT bonded in a Talisman Nomination Pool" - 1/4 DOT for staking 1 DOT, what? this people will stake anyway , with Talisman or without , there are a lot of teams who can explain people how to stake without asking 0,25% for every dot they stake.
  • "Any commission received by Talisman" - its Polkadot Network commission, not Talisman, what you are suggesting just crazy.
  • The Talisman nomination pools - you can monitize your nomination pools as validators, it can be good reward for your hard work. This proposal will centralize Polkadot more, you already have 2 pools , and will have a resources to advertise more nomination pools its also not good. Diversity is the key for success for Polkadot.

- This proposal are steps to privatize Polkadot network according interest of one entity (Talisman) , don't like it. Its not a good idea at all.

Reply
Up

Deleted Comment - Prev commented a reply to Promoteam without actually replying to their post.

Edited

Reply
Up