Referendum #385

Community Memecoin launch marketing campaign

Medium Spender
64 Comments
Executed
  • Content
  • AI Summary
Reply
Up 5
Share
Status
Decision28d
Confirmation1d
Attempts
1
Tally
61%Aye
59.2%Threshold
39%Nay
Aye
88.23MDOT
Nay
56.42MDOT
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

Threshold

Support(1.73%)
22.88MDOT
Issuance
1.32BDOT
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Calls
  • Call
  • Metadata
  • Timeline6
  • Votes Bubble
  • Statistics
    New
Comments

Marketing without a product? Also same agency, whit this proposal passing would be taking 130k DOT's from the tresury in just one month.... Should we not wait to see previous ones get excecuted then follow allong with another proposal with actually data from previous proposals?
Shitcoin connecting whit tresury is bad idea if it's community driven project community should finish building it and fund it. DOT has nothing with it, it was projects choice to choose DOT holders as elegible ones for Airdrop. Don't connect shitcoins with DOT. Thanks

Reply
Up

What happens if $DED is not finalized and idea about it is scratched? If there is no team behind it and its all "grassroots" community, who will be in charge of executing this project? One whale had an idea and he is pushing on his Agency on doing advertisment for non existing meme token.
Something does not seems right here.
We all know this is just a start of what G would grift from the tresurry for his project, TX's fees, LP's... then again "marketing"

Reply
Up

Hey! Have a few points I'd like to raise with this one. It seems like a bit of a money grab to be completely honest regardless of if they can or would deliver or not.

First of all, KOLs/influencers have been budgeted @ almost $600K in this proposal - I'd be interested in seeing a breakdown of pricing that reflects how much is gonna go to each influencer since this looks way too expensive, to say the least.

Also, considering some influencers are setting up proposals directly, so it can be a double spend. (like Ivan on Tech for example- https://polkadot.subsquare.io/referenda/382) - this is 100k for a year, this proposal talks about 600k for a lot less than a year of coverage.

Also, on the PR front - $60K for 12 articles is about 5x too expensive based on market research. Not sure I understand the need behind accepting such a proposal.

If we're gonna get 12 articles like the one Lunar gave as an example (see below), it shouldn't cost more than $10k for 12 articles.

https://blockchainreporter.net/is-a-memecoin-coming-to-polkadot-here-is-what-we-know/

Community activation & social media - same, not sure why this should cost $60k for 2 months of community management? pricing is off the charts.

This offer seems like it could maybe help DED if it was priced right and executed properly. I would say around 1/3 of the cost presented right now regardless of the execution.

Reply
Up

nice

Reply
Up

支持

Reply
Up

YES

Reply
Up

yes

Reply
Up

支持

Reply
Up