We would like to publicly support PlutoWallet's referendum with our rationale.
We believe that there are three the core areas on Polkadot require attention and improvements. The wallet ecosystem, the DeFi ecosystem and the explorer ecosystem. This will address the 1st area.
Comparatively with other ecosystems, the Polkadot wallet ecosystem still needs to mature. On other chains, wallets have different UIs and experiences which is also one of the ways of on-boarding users, by giving them flexibility on what to pick for their daily on-chain experience. On this regard we agree heavily with Rosta that teams and devs should be free to innovate into different directions, specially with one that users and developers will have to use on a day to day basis.
Them being PBA alumni is also a big plus as they are high quality talent and more often than not, are poached by other ecosystems for very good reasons.
For this reason. We will support this referendum and continuations of this referendum.
Hey, thank you for the proposal. I personally think that we don't need another wallet being paid by the treasury. The situation would maybe be different if you come back with X amount of active users, but right now I think we don't need it.
IMO this proposal would be much more useful for the ecosystem if you work together with the already existing wallets in the ecosystem.
Generally we want people like you in the ecosystem, but you should work on something which has a bigger impact. Right now we don't have any proper list of good tasks, but we are working on it. If you are interested, we can have a chat on what could be something that is better suited and brings more impact for the ecosystem.
I believe we really should ask ourselves if we need to have another wallet fully funded by the Polkadot treasury. Looking at the Android store the app so far has 100+ downloads which isn't much. The UI-design really does not meet standards and is unable to match others such as Novawallet or Talisman.
Your rates seem fair for the amount of work, but I do not see how spending $24.000 for NFT-support for an app with just a handful of downloads will result in a worthy return on investment. Furthermore, there are already plently of other options out there.