Referendum #1035

AssetPortal (Milestone 1)

Medium Spender
3mos ago
9 Comments
Executed
  • Content
  • AI Summary
Reply
Up
Share
Request
30,981DOT
Status
Decision28d
Confirmation4d
Attempts
1
Tally
85%Aye
50.0%Threshold
15%Nay
Aye
46.96MDOT
Nay
8.27MDOT
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%
  • 0.0%

Threshold

Support(0.92%)
13.5MDOT
Issuance
1.46BDOT
Votes
Nested
Flattened
Calls
  • Call
  • Metadata
  • Timeline6
  • Votes Bubble
  • Statistics
Comments

Hello and thank you for the proposal.
We appreciate the effort and the current PoC but we have some questions regarding this proposal that relate to integrations, future budget, future maintenance and legal+tax expenses.

First of all, we are very happy to see PBA alumni submitting an OpenGov proposal, staying on Polkadot to build and more importantly working on AssetHub, something that has been extremely needed for a while.

  1. We see that the teleport utility is currently showing all Polkadot parachains. Are there plans to integrate Hyperbridge (under development), Wormhole (live) and Snowbridge (recently live) assets to Assetportal? We see this as extremely important as these foreign assets, or local assets seeking teleportation to other chains are meant to be critical for future adoption, liquidity and integration of Polkadot with the wide crypto ecosystem. This item is not mentioned either on the Milestone 1 or 2 of the proposal. We only see mentions of KSM-DOT assets.
  2. There are currently 2 AssetHub swap projects (Kheopswap and Dotswap) and potentially more coming in the future. Will all of them be included as a backend or widget into Assetportal or will there be a preference towards a single exchange? We prefer that all possible candidates are included so users get to pick them in a similar way Defillama swap shows all exchanges without picking a favorite. This will be very important once AssetHub migrates to Plaza (more on this next).
  3. Do we have a concrete idea of the cost of the 2nd milestone? We are starting to ask about these costs in advance as we see that most projects leave that cost unspecified and OpenGov should be aware of the total cost of a project's completion.
  4. Will Plaza migration/upgrade require an additional funding proposal and/or restructuring. In a similar sense, what is it going to be the maintenance costs and plans after the delivery of milestone 2.
  5. Can you expand a bit more on the 27k USD as legal registration and tax consultancy? At first glance it seems rather on high end.

Looking forward to your answers.

Reply
Up

Hello @AssetPortal Team,

This project really looks interesting. I have sent you a personal email about a query. Do Let me know if you have received that mail.

Reply
Up