Hello [@Nmarshall](/user/15aVbh9j99DyEJo9pYDs6UMB25ybHAteb4xmjnXkiBx855Qo),

I think your proposal is missing details on Nishaun's track record so far. It's claimed that he's a rising star, but as someone who is completely unfamiliar with this field, I can't find any evidence in the proposal to back this claim. There should have been a substantial "Who is Nishaun Marshall" section in my opinion.

In summary:

- I don't find the asked amount too high.
- I don't think Polkadot treasury should sponsor everything listed in the proposal.
- It may or may not provide good return on investment, not enough evidence in the proposal, just some suggestions.
- At the given scale, it may be a good experiment for precedence purposes.
- So, I don't feel strongly either way.

I abstain.

Best regards,
kukabi | Helikon

Based on the feedback from community members and commenters, we will be withdrawing this proposal, and applying through the marketing bounty. We remain fans of Polkadot..

amount

beneficiary

Rejected

Submitted

DecisionStarted

DecisionDepositPlaced

small_spender

WHO: Not specified
WHAT: Withdrawing a proposal
PRICE/TIMEFRAME/RESOURCES: Not specified

Rising Karting Star Seeks Polkadot Partnership(withdrawn)

root

whitelisted_caller

wish_for_change

staking_admin

treasurer

lease_admin

fellowship_admin

general_admin

auction_admin

referendum_canceller

referendum_killer

small_tipper

big_tipper

medium_spender

big_spender

Origin able to dispatch a whitelisted call.

Origin for signaling that the network wishes for some change

Origin able to cancel slashes and manage minimum commission.

Origin for spending up to 10,000,000 DOT from the treasury as well as generally administering it.

Origin for managing the composition of the fellowship.

Origin able to spend around 250 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 1,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 10,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 100,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend up to 1,000,000 DOT from the treasury at once.